Sunday, February 11, 2018

Crisis in Maldives

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Two statements from China with regard to crisis in Maldives:
a) It is an internal matter and there should be no external intervention, and
b) We do not want another Doklam like situation with India.
Should put our concerns at rest with regard to the Chinese intentions in that island nation. Besides, China has also turned down a request from the Maldivian government to land its military boots in Maldives to secure its interests, stating that Maldives can secure itself.
But, parallels are being drawn with Operation Cactus, executed by India in 1988, to liberate Maldives from some mercenaries who were perhaps financed by some Maldivian national. This operation was carried out as per the request of then Maldivian President Gayoom, while in the current scenario is the Maldivian opposition which is requesting for military intervention by India.
Here, it is pertinent to recall the disaster which confronted the IPKF in Sri Lanka, which was originally tasked with ensuring peace between the Sri Lankan military and the LTTE cadres, but soon got engulfed in a situation which it was least prepared for.
Right now, even though we have erroneously refused to entertain the special Maldivian envoy, quoting reasons such as time constraint etc, we need to be in constant touch with the Maldivian Ambassador in New Delhi, and be clear on our expectations from their current President, as well as the options at our disposal should any off those options be required to be availed. Yes, our leadership has done the right thing by taking the US as well as Saudi Arabia on board vis a is Maldives, and as per the newspaper reports we are in touch with the Chinese as well on this issue.
But, it would have been reassuring if the Chinese leadership would have emphasized to the Maldivian President to restore democracy and will of the people, to prevent any civil war kind of scenario. That such as statement is yet to come from the Chinese is a matter of concern, notwithstanding that they themselves are yet to demonstrate their commitment to such principles.
Till then, its wait and watch, and hope that the will of people of Maldives reigns supreme, without having to land even a single foreign soldier and without having to fire even a single bullet



Monday, January 15, 2018

An Unprecedented Press Conference

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs


I had once read somewhere that, the Hon'ble Judges should be heard only vide their judicial pronouncements, which could have far reaching consequences for the society at large, besides meeting the ends of justice which is expected through such legal luminaries, who have been entrusted with such coveted positions in our legal system.

The unprecedented press conference by four of the distinguished judges of our highest citadel of justice- our Hon'ble Supreme Court - seems to have belittled the said assertion.

Having gone through the detailed coverage in Times of India dated 13th of January, my observations are as follows:

a) Any case which gets referred to and then admitted in the Hon'ble Supreme Court, has a significance over and above all the cases under adjudication in any court of our country, including our Hon'ble High Courts. Thus, the opinion that certain cases referred to and admitted in the Hon'ble Supreme Court could be of far reaching consequences' for the Nation relative to other cases under adjudication in the Hon'ble Supreme Court, can at best be a matter of perception, at least where the interest of our media in such cases is concerned, 
b) That the collegium system of appointment of judges to the Hon'ble Supreme Court is flawed because of which some of its Hon'ble Judges, are not competent enough to handle cases which are deemed 'politically sensitive', can be debated endlessly. The final trigger for the stunning press conference by the four of the senior most judges came at 10.15 am on 12th of January, when the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India - Dipak Misra, bluntly turned down their last minute request to shift a 'politically sensitive' case from a particular bench. The Hon'ble CJI made it clear that he would not break the tradition, backed by a recent five-judge bench decision giving him the sole discretion to assign cases to benches of his choice. The Hon'ble CJI's decision was backed by the November 2017 verdict saying that CJI was 'master of the roster' and was free too sign cases to any bench,
c) A letter written earlier by the four judges to the Hon'ble CJI also mentioned that "The convention of recognising the privilege of the CJI to form roster and assign cases to different members/benches of the Supreme court is a convention devised for disciplined and efficient transaction of business of the court, but not a recognition of any superior authority, legal or factual, of the CJI over his colleagues. It is too well settled in the jurisprudence of this country that the CJI is only first among equals - nothing more and nothing less." The Hon'ble CJI's office responded by saying "if these senior most judges were equal to the so called junior judges in the Court, then what is the grievance against a case getting listed before judge X or judge Y?"
d) Now, if the intention of any of these four distinguished judges were to protect the interests of the quality of justice being delivered by our highest citadel of justice, then at least one of them should have resigned as judge, and as a practicing advocate appealed against the November 2017 decision of the five-judge bench, which gave the Hon'ble CJI absolute authority in assigning cases to respective benches of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Or, at the very least even without stepping down, should have informally evolved consensus within the twenty -five of their colleagues in the Hon'ble Supreme Court, with regard to the appropriate procedures to be adopted by the Hon'ble CJI while assigning cases. This would have been very difficult for the Hon'ble CJI to ignore,
e) The perception one gets from the sequence of events as highlighted in Times of India dated 13th of January, is that these four distinguished judges have implicitly attacked the collegium system of appointment of judges, which is indeed ironic, considering that they themselves are the beneficiaries of the said collegium system. Why can't they be explicit and evolve a consensus within the legal fraternity about it? Why just go to the media to air their grievances thereby shocking "We the People of India" ?
f) Finally, I am compelled to agree with the observations of Justice (Retired) R.S. Sodhi, who has been quoted in the said Times Of India, "All the four judges should be impeached, they have no business to sit here and deliver verdicts anymore. This trade unionism is wrong...They are only four, there are twenty three others. Four get together and show Chief Justice in a poor light. It is immature and childish behaviour. We have dissenting views on so many things. But we do not go around washing our dirty linen in public...judicial impropriety.. The damage can't be mended easily."
Hope and pray that this ill-conceived press conference was just another aberration, in the otherwise much cherished history and track record of our judicial system. 
Yes, with changing times, our judicial system may have lots more to be desired, and those much desired changes come about in a dignified manner, which only reinforces the faith and confidence of "We the People of India". Amen

Thursday, January 11, 2018

Turning Around the 'Maharaja'

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Air India was certainly like a blotting paper for our government, having consumed nearly Rs. 43,000 crores in hope of a turnaround, but without any signs of revival as yet.
Yes, announcing a 49% FDI in it was a welcome cheer for the international community, as our treasury could not continue bleeding indefinitely because of it.
But before doing so, was it not possible for our government to try giving full autonomy to its management and staff, for turning around our NationalCarrier? Had this attempt failed, we could have invited our private sector to bid for a majority stake in the airline, and only then could we have invited FDI.
Certainly, ridding the 'Maharaja' of political interference, allowing its current management of doing away with 'n' no of subsidized tickets and freebies, reworking its nonviable routes, and above all matching up to its private counterparts in terms of efficiency and services, could have also delivered the intended results.
And what could have been the real 'killer stroke' is making its staff category employees a partner, by making them eligible for part of its profits. Its so-called union would have become redundant, and they would have delivered more than their 100% to the make our 'Maharaja a Royal Entity' among our PSUs.

Sunday, December 17, 2017

Indo-Pak Relations

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Read an interesting news item today, "India's new envoy to Pakistan could face rough ride ahead".
No doubt, an assignment in Pakistan for any Indian diplomat could be a real test of nerves and diplomatic skills, considering the fragile nature of our bilateral ties, besides the power equations in Pakistan between their civilian and military leadership. Its any one's guess who calls the shots where foreign policies via a-vis India are concerned.
Without doubting our envoy - Mr. Ajay Bisaria's diplomatic skills and his commitment, it would be great if more emphasis is also laid on military to military ties, via increase in the number of military attaches in both state capitals. They should be tasked with direct dealing with the defense establishments in the respective state capitals, and coordinate the outcomes via their envoys in the respective state capitals.
The role of civilian leadership at least in India, for such an ambitious exercise, would be a facilitation and a consultative one.

Friday, November 24, 2017

Hafiz Saeed's expected release

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Hafiz Saeed's expected release should not come as a surprise. What can the courts in Pakistan do, if their government did not pursue the matter seriously? Lakhvi, another key player who orchestrated the Mumbai attacks, was given all facilities in jail, including conjugal rights.
One needs to be reminded of the response of the then Foreign Secretary of Pakistan Mr. Salman Bashir, to our dossiers submitted. He trashed them as "piece of literature".
American and Israeli citizens were also targeted in those attacks, and now it is high time that we join efforts with Israel and US to isolate Pakistan globally on the issue of terrorism. Wonder, how long can Pakistan's chief patron China, keep shielding Pak based terrorists at the UNSC?
India needs to play a key back channel diplomacy in ensuring the relations between US and Iran are back on track. If that is accomplished, then India could facilitate the supplies to US troops in Afghanistan via Chabahar port in Iran, thereby effectively denting a key advantage which Pakistan has vis-a-vis US now, and that is, of providing routes via its soil for supplies to US troops in Afghanistan.

Thursday, November 9, 2017

Demonetization Exercise

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

One can debate endlessly on the merits and demerits of demonetization exercise. The key factor would lie in having credible information on the jobs created in the informal sector, which was hit badly last year due to cash crunch.

The government must make all out efforts to identify those badly hit, extent of job losses, and dole out loans on soft terms to such entities so that they are able to stand back on their feet, with greater vigor and energy, besides creating many more jobs than what were lost.

Perhaps, the gains made by RBI via decrease in its liabilities on account of those notes which have not entered the banking system as yet, as well as from the unaccounted cash seized from various bank accounts or other sources, could part finance such an initiative.

Saturday, April 1, 2017

SC Order on Dry Highways

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Reference to order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, which banned the sale of alcoholic beverages at establishments located within 500 meters of state and national highways, and included hotels, pubs and bars as well within its ambit, while allowing a partial modification reducing the limit to 220 meters in areas with a population of less than 20.000.

Some thoughts on above: :

a   1.  The said order from the Hon'ble Supreme Court court is based on the premise,  Drunk driving is a potent cause of fatalities and injuries in road accidents. The Constitution preserves and protects right to life as on over-arching constitutional value.

There can be no doubt about the validity of this premise by the bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, which delivered the said verdict yesterday. But then, can drunk driving not emanate from the residential units as well, situated along the prescribed limits off highways? Is there any empirical evidence to support the contention that only the impacted bars, pubs, and hotels located within such prescribed limits are responsible for drunk driving?

Secondly, should the resident guests in the impacted hotels, and guests in valet driven cars who visit such impacted bars, or pubs etc  not be permitted to consume liquor within such premises, as they do not cause drunk driving?

b   2. To quote from page no. 8 of today’s Hindustan Times (New Delhi/Metro edition): 
h     
       The  fresh ruling virtually rejected Attorney General Rohtagi’s legal opinion to Kerala and Haryana, that the verdict was not meant for restaurants, bars, and hotels.  “As the object of the direction is to prevent drunk driving, making any such relaxation will defeat its purpose”, the bench said.

But then, can’t drunk driving emanate from other bars, pubs, clubs, and hotels as well, which are off the prescribed limits, and do not come with the ambit of such prescribed limits as defined in the said judgement? Also, what about the residential units from where drunk driving can emanate, irrespective of where those are located?

It needs to be noted that as the Attorney General is the Chief Judicial Officer of the Union Government, his legal opinion to Kerala and Haryana, should represent the views of the Union Government as well.

In case of a clash between the Judiciary and the Executive, where interpretation of laws are concerned, the Executive can have an upper hand by promulgating an ordinance, to set aside the ruling of the Judiciary.
     
    3  To quote from page no. 8 of today’s Hindustan Times (New Delhi/Metro edition): 

       The Attorney General Mukul Rohtagi appearing for Tamil Nadu, argued that the order required rectification because the court had “transgressed its limitations” by interfering with the state’s right to prescribe distance. His argument, did not find favour with the court.

This implies that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has perhaps stepped on the rights of the states where this particular ruling is concerned. 

d  4. To quote from the front page of today’s Economic Times (New Delhi/Gurgaon edition),

      However, the bench did not relax the norm for hotels and restaurants, which risk losing their liquor licenses unless civic authorities re-designate highways as municipal roads.” As a parallel move, the state and the Union governments need to look afresh the existing highways, and evolve parameters to clearly define municipal roads and highways.  
     
          As a parallel move, the State and the Union governments need to look afresh the existing highways, and evolve parameters to clearly define municipal roads and highways.       
According to Google: 

A highway is a main road, or thoroughfare, such a street, boulevard, or parkway, available to the public for use for travel or transportation. The nature of public way is determinable from its origin, as well as the intention and plans of the appropriate authorities and the use to which it has been put.  If a particular road or highway is designated as private, its character will not be altered if it is actually a public road or a highway.

Private roads are intended for use by a few private individuals,as distinguished from highways that are for public use.      

                The said definition of Highway, if applied in the current ruling, would imply virtual prohibition in the country.